Here is the official, non-elitist, conservative, I-know-what-I’m-talking-about, tweezle.net analysis of the reasons that Republicans lost in 2008.
1). They fielded a flawed candidate. McCain made it clear long ago that he has no friends among those who claim authentic conservatism. The McCain-Feingold (so-called) Campaign Finance Reform (look where THAT got us!), the amnesty for illegals, the “gang of 14″ that set the table for a feast of liberal activist judges in the next few years, and a number of other initiatives that McCain either sponsored or vocally supported were not forgotten by the common person out in worthless fly-over country (like Alabama). It was impossible during the primaries to really support the man, unless you were already one of the party elites. His long friendship with the media also hurt him, since “journalists” had long ago abandoned any pretense of impartiality. It was difficult to make a case about Obama’s questionable associations when McCain’s were similarly questionable (not to the same degree of radicalism, mind you, but in the principle of suspicious behavior). McCain could not excite the entire country as someone like a Thompson or Huckabee or Romney could have.
2). They waged a flawed campaign. There was never any unifying response to any stimulus from the other side. The “Country First” slogan was great, but it was little utilized (at least to my recollection). There were issues galore that could have been easily appropriated and broadcast as ads or (*gasp!*) talking points. Things Obama and Biden said, things their supporters said, the past questionable associations of Obama, his checkered and little-known past, his seldom-reported voting record in the Illinois and US Senates, and many other examples exist of things that could have been exploited successfully. The “Joe the Plumber” incident was probably the greatest moment of the campaign. If they had treated other issues with the same amount of intensity and coverage, many minds may have been changed.
3). They relied on flawed supporters. These were the usual suspects that look down their noses at the unwashed masses anywhere in the country except the Northeast Corridor. This was exemplified by their treatment of Governor Palin. She did nothing wrong, but she was excoriated mercilessly simply because she was not “one of them”. The vitriol continues days after the election is over. She was an outsider, and that’s ultimately why many well-known names abandoned the McCain bus. They wanted to avoid soiling their doilies with the mud and guts that that Alaskan hillbilly would have tracked into their upscale condos. These writers and commentators who deliberately sabotaged their own party because of their elite snobbery should be either tarred and feathered, run out of town on a rail, have their “pansy-of-the-month” subscription canceled, or a mixture of any or all of the above.
4). They listened to the “conventional wisdom”. This “knowledge” of “how things are done” has proven to be totally devoid of worth. The “bipartisanship” that the other side speaks of is not “bi’ at all, but totally one-sided. When they are in power, conservatives are to abandon principle and follow their lead. When they are in the minority, conservatives are to back away and listen to them, not “shoving ideology down their throats”. The average citizen, the church-going faithful, the dirty-handed serfs are to be feared, not listened to or considered worthy of anything but contempt (see Sarah Palin for an example). My opinions, expressed here on the blog page that I pay for and maintain, are worthless blatherings of some type of deranged individual. What do I know? I am to be feared or ignored, just like anyone else that does not have the “blue blood” that REAL Republicans have.
Those are 4 brief thoughts. The conclusion of the matter, to me, is that we either need a drastic shakeup in the makeup of the Republican party, or we need a new, strong, fundamentally conservative party that is fearless in standing up for principles of morality, open and ethical government, the rule of law as embodied in the Constitution, and the freedoms granted to us by God and secured for us by the protections (NOT limitations) of a freely and honestly elected government.
Unfortunately, it probably won’t happen. Not in what’s left of my lifetime, anyway.